Website Redesign or Marketing Strategy: Which Do You Need First?

A founder asks me this most weeks. The website looks dated, enquiries are flat, and a redesign feels like the obvious move.

Sometimes it is. More often the website is not the constraint, and redesigning it is an expensive way to stay exactly where you are.

The test: can you brief the redesign?

Imagine you have hired a designer and they ask three questions.

1. Who is this site for, specifically enough to exclude people?
2. What one thing should a visitor understand in the first ten seconds?
3. What should they do next, and why is that the right first step?

If you cannot answer all three, a redesign will not fix your problem. It will produce a better-looking version of the same confusion, and you will have spent the budget.

When the website genuinely is the problem

There are real cases where the site is the bottleneck.

• It is slow, or it does not work properly on a phone.
• You cannot edit it without paying someone.
• It says something you no longer do, or misses something you now lead with.
• Your buyers have changed and the site still speaks to the old ones.

Those are structural. No amount of strategy fixes a site nobody can update.

When strategy has to come first

If your enquiries are flat but the site works, the problem is upstream.

Usually one of three things: the wrong people are arriving, the right people are arriving and not understanding the offer, or they understand it and the next step is too big.

I have written about the five reasons a site gets traffic but no enquiries. Four of the five are not design problems, and a redesign would have solved none of them.

The sequence that works

Direction, then positioning, then the site.

Decide who you are for and what you want to be known for. Write the offer in words a buyer would recognise. Then brief the redesign against that, and the design decisions mostly make themselves.

Done in that order, a redesign is a much smaller project than it looks, and sometimes no redesign is needed at all. Done first, it becomes a series of taste arguments nobody can settle, because there is no agreed standard to settle them against.

Where to start

If you cannot answer the three briefing questions today, spend a fraction of the redesign budget answering them properly. The redesign gets cheaper, faster and better, and you may find you need less of one than you thought.

---

Not sure which part to fix first?

Most founder-led businesses are not short of marketing activity. They are short of a decision about what matters. The Founder-Led Marketing Scorecard takes about three minutes and tells you which of seven areas is holding the rest back.